Falling Incidents
Experienced Legal Help for Nursing Home Residents Hurt in a Fall
Falls are a leading cause of traumatic injury among people over age 55 across the country. Falls can lead to broken hips, dislocated joints, head trauma, and other serious injuries. When we place our elderly or disabled loved ones in a nursing home, we expect these facilities to take extra care to protect against falls. If a nursing home, assisted living facility, home health aide, rehabilitation facility, or other long-term care facility fails in its duty to adequately monitor and care for your family member, the team at Levinson Law, P.C., is ready to hear your case.
When Are Nursing Homes Liable for a Fall?
Nursing homes are like any other property. If a person slips and falls on someone else’s property, then the fall victim might be able to bring a premises liability lawsuit, depending on what led to the injury. If the victim slipped or tripped due to a hazard on the premises, then the owner or operator of the property could be liable. The same applies to nursing homes.
Nursing homes, moreover, may be liable for resident falls under a theory of medical negligence. Premises liability is based on the duty that a landowner owes to a guest. Nursing home residents are also owed a higher duty of care by nurses and other long-term care facility staff. Nursing home residents are often at greater risk of a fall due to being elderly or disabled, and part of a nursing home’s duty is to take extra precautions to ensure that a fall does not happen.
If a resident is injured in a fall, it is important to ask what measures the nursing home had in place to prevent fall injuries. For example: What type of floors does the nursing home have? What type of footwear was the resident wearing? What protocols does the facility have in place to prevent falls? What were the staffing requirements? Does the resident’s medical history indicate an increased risk for falls? A knowledgeable Tulsa nursing home fall attorney will help you investigate the answers to these questions in order to determine if a nursing home should be held liable after a resident is injured in a fall.
How do Nursing Home Falls Happen?
Slips, trips, and falls in nursing homes can happen for a variety of reasons. While the usual factors that can lead to a slip and fall also apply–wet floors, slippery carpets, hidden steps, etc.–nursing home residents typically have a higher risk of being injured in a fall than the average person.
Factors that can contribute to a nursing home fall include the following:
- Failure to monitor patients
- Failure to clean up or warn about a wet floor
- Bed rail malfunction
- Safety bar malfunction
- Discarded objects or other hazards on the floor
- Failure to supervise at-risk patients walking in the facility
- Failure to set a bed at a proper height for the specific patient
- Defective or broken medical assistance devices such as canes or walkers
- Mishandled transferring of a patient by the staff
- Inadequate lighting
Nursing homes can and should employ a variety of safety measures to prevent and lessen the damage caused by falls, including bathroom checks, bed alarms, bed positioning and placement, and ensuring adequate staffing. If your elderly or disabled loved one was injured in a preventable fall, speak with a nursing home fall lawyer at Levinson Law, P.C., to investigate the fall and determine if the nursing home should be held liable.
Fall Prevention Nursing Homes Must Provide
Most nursing home falls come from a mix of health problems and hazards in the building. Common health risks include lower-body weakness, trouble with balance or walking, vitamin D deficiency, foot pain, poor vision and medications that cause dizziness or drowsiness. Common hazards include slippery floors, loose carpeting, clutter, poor lighting, poor footwear and missing grab bars or railings.
Oklahoma and federal law require nursing homes to take reasonable steps to keep residents from falling. Those steps include:
- Assessing each resident’s fall risk on admission and again when their condition changes;
- Closely supervising residents who are at high risk;
- Providing walkers, wheelchairs, proper shoes and other aids;
- Having a doctor or pharmacist review medications that affect balance;
- Installing grab bars and handrails in bathrooms, bedrooms and hallways;
- Cleaning up spills quickly and keeping walkways clear and well lit;
- Keeping beds at a safe height and repairing broken equipment right away; and
- Training staff to move and transfer residents safely.
Bed Rail Injuries
Bed rails are often used to keep residents from rolling out of bed, but they can be deadly. A frail or confused resident can become trapped between the rail and the mattress and be strangled or suffocated, and a resident who tries to climb over a rail can fall from a greater height. Federal rules require a nursing home to try appropriate alternatives before installing a bed rail, assess the resident’s risk of entrapment, review the risks and benefits with the resident or their representative and get informed consent, make sure the bed is the right size for the resident, and install the rail according to the manufacturer’s instructions. When a facility skips these steps and a resident is hurt, the facility can be held responsible.
Wheelchair and Transfer Injuries
Many falls happen when a resident is moved from a bed to a wheelchair, toilet or shower chair. Staff who are poorly trained, rushed or working alone can drop a resident or let them fall. Residents also fall out of wheelchairs when the chair catches on something while being pushed, when they are not properly secured, or when they try to get up without help because no one answered the call light. Seat alarms, regular checks on power chairs and scooters, and enough staff to help with transfers can prevent many of these injuries.
The Harm a Fall Can Cause
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, about one in five falls among older adults causes a serious injury, such as a broken bone or a head injury. Older adults heal slowly, and a fall can lead to surgery, long periods in bed, bedsores, pneumonia and a loss of independence. Many residents who fall develop a fear of falling and become less active, which weakens them further and makes another fall more likely. See also our pages on broken bones and paralysis.
Fall Risk Assessments and Care Plans
A fall in a nursing home is not always preventable, but many are. Facilities are expected to assess each resident’s fall risk when they are admitted, after a change in condition, and after any fall. Common tools include the Morse Fall Scale and the facility’s own screening forms, and the findings should shape the resident’s written care plan. Risk factors include a history of falls, weak legs or poor balance, dementia, poor vision, urinary urgency, low blood pressure, and medications that cause drowsiness or dizziness. When a resident is known to be at risk, the care plan should say what staff will do about it, such as scheduled toileting, a bed or chair alarm, a low bed, non-slip footwear, a walker within reach, or closer supervision.
Federal regulations (42 C.F.R. § 483.25(d)) require a nursing home to keep the resident environment as free of accident hazards as possible and to provide adequate supervision and assistance devices to prevent accidents. A care plan that is never followed, or never updated after a fall, can be as important as the fall itself.
Staffing, Call Lights and Equipment
Many falls happen when a resident tries to get to the bathroom alone because no one answered the call light. Short staffing, nights and weekends, shift changes and meal times are common pressure points. Other causes include wet or cluttered floors, poor lighting, broken wheelchair brakes, bed rails that are misused, unsafe transfers that need two staff members but get one, and mechanical lifts used incorrectly. Staffing records, call light logs and maintenance records can show whether a pattern existed before the fall.
What Should Happen After a Fall
After a fall, staff should check the resident for injury, call the nurse, and monitor for changes. A resident who hits their head or whose fall was not witnessed needs closer monitoring, because a serious injury such as a head bleed or a hip fracture can be hard to spot at first. The resident’s physician and family representative should be told about an accident that causes injury, and the facility should complete an incident report and review whether the care plan needs to change. Warning signs of a poor response include delayed transfer to the hospital, complaints of pain that are dismissed, unexplained bruising, and a family that learns about a fall days later.
Evidence in a Nursing Home Fall Case
Helpful evidence may include the admission paperwork and fall risk assessments, the care plan, nursing notes, the incident report, medication records, staffing schedules, call light data, maintenance logs, and any photographs or video. Families can ask for the resident’s records, take dated photographs of injuries and the room, write down who said what and when, and avoid signing documents they do not understand. State inspection reports, which are public, may show earlier citations for falls or supervision problems at the same facility.
What Compensation May Cover
Depending on the facts, a claim may seek compensation for medical bills, hospital and rehabilitation costs, ongoing care, pain and suffering, loss of mobility and independence, and, when a fall leads to a death, damages available in a wrongful death case. Every case is different, and no lawyer can promise a particular result.
Common Questions About Nursing Home Falls
Is every fall the nursing home’s fault? No. Residents can fall even with good care. The question is whether the facility knew of the risk, took reasonable steps to reduce it, and responded properly afterward.
Can a fall be neglect even if the resident was not badly hurt? It can. Repeated falls, or repeated failures to follow the care plan, may point to a larger problem that deserves attention before someone is seriously injured.
Who can bring a claim? The resident, or someone acting for them, such as a legally authorized representative. If the resident has died, a wrongful death claim is brought by the personal representative of the estate.
Reporting Suspected Fall-Related Neglect in an Oklahoma Nursing Home
If a resident is in immediate danger or needs urgent medical care, call 911 first. Concerns can also be reported to the Oklahoma Human Services Abuse and Neglect Hotline at 1-800-522-3511 (available 24 hours a day), to the Oklahoma State Department of Health nursing facility complaint line at 1-800-747-8419, or to the Long-Term Care Ombudsman through the intake line at (405) 521-6734. Oklahoma law (43A O.S. § 10-104) places a duty to report suspected abuse, neglect or exploitation of a vulnerable adult on people who have reason to believe it is happening. Making a report to an agency is separate from deciding whether to speak with a lawyer, and families can do both.
How Oklahoma Law Applies to Nursing Home Fall Claims
The Oklahoma Nursing Home Care Act (63 O.S. § 1-1939) allows a resident, or someone acting for the resident, to bring a civil action against a facility’s owner or licensee for the negligent or intentional acts of its staff. The statute also allows a court to order a facility to stop unlawful practices, makes a waiver of these rights void, and protects residents and others from retaliation for asserting them. Nursing homes that take Medicare or Medicaid must also follow federal requirements in 42 C.F.R. Part 483, which cover quality of care, care planning, staffing, resident rights and freedom from abuse and neglect.
Deadlines matter. Oklahoma’s general deadline for personal injury lawsuits is two years (12 O.S. § 95(A)(3)), and a wrongful death action must be commenced within two years under 12 O.S. § 1053. Some claims against health care providers fall under 76 O.S. § 18, which also uses a two-year period measured from when the injury was or should have been discovered. Which rule applies depends on the facts, so it is wise to ask a lawyer about timing as soon as possible. Oklahoma also follows a modified comparative fault rule (23 O.S. § 13), so a facility may argue that someone else shares the blame, and a plaintiff found more than 50 percent at fault is barred from recovery.
This page gives general information about Oklahoma law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship, every case depends on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. To discuss your situation, contact Levinson Law, P.C. at 918-492-4433.
Get Help from a Dedicated Lawyer Today
Your elderly or disabled family member deserves proper care and attention while residing in a Tulsa nursing home. If nursing home negligence or abuse leads to your loved one being hurt in a fall, the lawyers at Levinson Law, P.C., are ready to help you seek compensation for their injuries. Please call Levinson Law, P.C., today to set up a free initial meeting, or use our website’s convenient contact form for a prompt, private response to your questions.